Things vs Todoist vs Notes: Pick the Right App


One-time cost, gamified goals, or just free and simple?

June 18, 2025

By: Markus Estrada

Small Project Digest logo imageProduction Brief

Introduction:

I’ve spent way too much time trying to figure out how to get things done, and ironically, half of that time was wasted bouncing between apps that were supposed to help me do exactly that. I’m talking about Things, Todoist, and the deceptively simple Apple Notes. All three promise productivity. All three say they’ll change your life. But only one has actually stuck for me — and there’s a reason why.

Key Takeaways

App Best For Pricing
Things Mac/iOS users who want simplicity with power One-time purchase
Todoist Gamified productivity lovers Subscription-based
Apple Notes Basic users looking for free integration Free
screenshot of things app on mobile and desktop

1. Things App

Things is the productivity app I keep coming back to. It’s like the vinyl of task managers — clean, satisfying, and just works. It doesn’t overwhelm you with notifications or throw you into some black hole of productivity scoring. It’s there when you need it, and it integrates with a surprising number of third-party apps like Zapier or calendar plugins.

Pros:

  • One-time payment (no subscriptions, hallelujah)
  • Polished interface that’s almost therapeutic
  • Works beautifully on Mac, iPhone, and iPad
  • Great for structured workflows and recurring tasks

Cons:

  • Only available for Apple users
  • No native Android or Windows support
  • Collaboration is very limited
screenshot of todoist karma

2. Todoist App

Todoist is the app that makes you feel productive even when you’re not. That’s both the beauty and the trap. The gamification — with its karma levels and streaks — is addictive. But that can easily become a rabbit hole where you’re optimizing your productivity system instead of, you know, doing the actual thing.

Pros:

  • Cross-platform support: iOS, Android, web, Windows, you name it
  • Gamification keeps motivation high
  • Excellent for team collaboration and shared projects
  • Powerful filtering, labels, and templates

Cons:

  • Subscription model (starts at $4/month billed annually)
  • Can become overwhelming with features
  • Easily leads to “productivity theater”
screenshot of apple notes in app store

3. Apple Notes

Apple Notes is like that friend you’ve known forever — reliable, a little plain, but always shows up. It’s free, deeply integrated with Apple’s ecosystem, and even works with Siri (“Hey Siri, create a note…”). I gave it a real try, mostly because of how fast it syncs across my devices and how dead simple it is to capture thoughts.

Pros:

  • 100% free and pre-installed on Apple devices
  • Works great with Siri and native scheduling apps
  • Syncs instantly with iCloud
  • Supports rich media and checklists

Cons:

  • Limited for structured task management
  • Minimal integration with third-party automation
  • Harder to build a daily system around it
overhead photo of book and phone and coffee

4. Final Thoughts

If you’re trying to decide between Things, Todoist, and Apple Notes, it really comes down to your style. Are you a minimalist who just wants a focused tool? Go with Things. Need cross-platform collaboration and don’t mind a few dopamine hits from productivity karma? Todoist’s your jam. Want dead-simple, free, and native to your iPhone or Mac? Then Apple Notes will do the trick.

Me? I’ve tried ‘em all, but I keep coming back to Things. It doesn’t shout. It doesn’t nag. It’s just there, quietly keeping my brain from melting. And I only paid once for it. That’s a win in my book.

About the Author:

Website and Automotive Industry Professional. Designer/Developer, Writer, Musician.
Member of the Advisory Board at University of California Irvine, Continuing Education, Coding Bootcamp.

Recommended Posts


Get the Brief!

Receive inspiration, tips, and the latest design trends directly in your inbox. Enhance your daily workflow with a curated, passionate approach to design and project management. Cultivate your skills and become part of a community of dedicated creatives. Enter your email address below and Subscribe.

By signing up, you agree to receive emails from Project Digest, including newsletters and promotional content. You can unsubscribe at any time. View Privacy Policy
Top